Assessment and evaluation

What is summative assessment?

Definition

Summative assessment is the evaluation of learning once a unit, a course, or a program ends. It measures what learners achieved against a standard or benchmark.

Key takeaways

  • Judges achievement against a set standard once instruction ends
  • Can be a test, written work, a presentation, a project, or a portfolio
  • A detailed rubric that names the learning goals is usually needed for higher-stakes grading
  • Often high stakes, and almost always formally graded, though grading isn’t required

Why summative assessment matters

Once a unit or course ends, summative assessment tells a training team whether each learner met a standard or benchmark. In one study of workplace-based learning, every check counted toward the final go or no-go decision. As a result, students came to see checks meant as formative feedback as summative and found the formative side hard to focus on [3].

Types of summative assessment

Once the stakes rise, grading usually needs a detailed rubric that lists the learning goals being judged. Portfolios, presentations, and video projects are among the kinds of work where a rubric matters especially.

  • Exams and tests
    Exams such as a midterm, an exam the instructor writes, or a standardized test. In a workplace course, this could be the final quiz a learner takes before the course counts as complete.
  • Papers, essays, and reports
    Written work such as a paper, a final essay, or a final report. On a management course, it might be a written plan for applying the course with the learner’s own team.
  • Oral and final presentations
    Learners give an oral or final presentation. In sales training, the equivalent might be a pitch to a mock buyer, scored against the course’s learning goals.
  • Final projects
    A final project, a mini-project, or a video that learners create. A customer education team might ask learners to build a short how-to video for a product they support.
  • Portfolios
    Learners create a portfolio of their work. In the same study, turning many separate assessments into one overall portfolio verdict called for skilled judges who had long training and ongoing supervision [3].

Summative assessment example

A training provider’s assessment lead is closing a forklift-safety certification course. The lead writes a final exam that covers the course’s learning goals and sets the benchmark each learner must meet. Learners sit the exam only after instruction has ended, which makes it summative. Last, the lead judges each result against that benchmark to see who reached the standard. That is the exams and tests type of summative assessment at work.

Summative assessment vs formative assessment

Formative assessment runs while learning is still under way. It gives ongoing feedback that instructors and learners can use to improve, while summative assessment judges the result at the end. Pairing the two can support learning as time goes on.

CriterionSummative assessmentFormative assessment
TimingAt the close of a unit, course, or whole programDuring the course, while learning is under way
Main jobJudge achievement against a standard or benchmarkFeed back on progress so teaching and learning can improve
Typical stakesOften high stakesGenerally low stakes
Common formatsSuch as tests, papers, oral presentations, or portfoliosSuch as in-class discussions, practice problems, or low-stakes quizzes

How LearnWorlds supports this

Summative assessment in LearnWorlds

The LearnWorlds assessment builder can deliver a unique set of questions to each respondent in a random order. Test time is measured on the server side. You can also identify whether each respondent passed or failed, along with their answers and the grade they received.

FAQ

Summative assessment exists to give a final, measurable account of what learners achieved by the end of instruction [1]. Yale’s Poorvu Center credits this aim to Maki, writing in 2002. Learners and instructors can also use those results to steer their effort in later courses.

Summative evaluation is a study at the close of an education or training action, or one phase of it. The study checks how far the expected outcomes were reached. The European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (Cedefop) treats it and summative assessment as one term. A summative evaluation is meant to show what the action was worth.

Whether a quiz counts as a summative assessment can depend on when it comes in the course. One activity can sometimes serve either purpose, depending on the point in the course where it comes. One university teaching guide lists low-stakes quizzes among its formative examples and tests among its summative ones.

A summative assessment grade often carries heavy weight, but it doesn’t have to. Nearly every summative assessment gets a formal grade, though that isn’t required either.

References

  1. Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning, Yale University. Formative & summative assessments. Yale University.
  2. Eberly Center, Carnegie Mellon University. Formative vs summative assessment. Carnegie Mellon University.
  3. Bok, H. G. J., Teunissen, P. W., Favier, R. P., Rietbroek, N. J., Theyse, L. F. H., Brommer, H., Haarhuis, J. C. M., van Beukelen, P., van der Vleuten, C. P. M., & Jaarsma, D. A. D. C. (2013). Programmatic assessment of competency-based workplace learning: when theory meets practice. BMC Medical Education, 13, 123 (PubMed Central).
  4. Center for Innovation in Teaching & Learning, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Distinguishing between formative and summative assessments. University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.
  5. Cedefop (European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training). Summative assessment / summative evaluation. Cedefop VET glossary.

Related terms

Assessment and evaluation

Formative assessment

Checking how learning is going during a course, so instructors and learners get feedback they can use to improve teaching and learning.

Read definition

Assessment and evaluation

Question bank

A question bank is a reusable store of test questions, tagged by topic and difficulty, that teams draw on to build quizzes and exams.

Read definition

Assessment and evaluation

Competency-based learning

Competency-based learning is an approach where learners advance by demonstrating defined skills and knowledge, at a pace that varies by learner.

Read definition

Assessment and evaluation

Kirkpatrick Model

A four-level framework for evaluating training, from how people react and what they learn to how they act at work and what results follow.

Read definition

Build quizzes with automatic grading

Create quizzes with reusable question pools and automatic grading for objective questions, then review every learner's answers.

Published:

Last Update: