Instructional design

What is mastery learning?

Definition

Mastery learning is an instructional strategy where learners must reach a set mastery level on each unit before moving to the next. The goal is for all or nearly all learners to master the content.

Key takeaways

  • Each unit has a mastery standard that learners meet before they continue
  • Unit assessments give feedback instead of closing the unit
  • Correctives teach the content a different way, then a parallel assessment checks again
  • First-time passers can move on to enrichment
  • Feedback, extra assessment versions, and tracking add workload

Why mastery learning matters

In Bloom’s view, most end-of-unit tests did little beyond showing which learners the first round of teaching suited. Mastery learning uses that assessment mainly as feedback instead. Kulik’s 1990 meta-analysis pooled 36 studies of the method and reported a mean effect size of 0.59 [1]. The catch is workload, since each unit needs feedback, several assessment versions, and tracking.

How mastery learning works

Guskey sets out five steps for designing mastery learning.

  • Specify the learning goals
    Decide which concepts and skills every learner needs to learn well. Pitch the level as well, for example recall, applying skills to a problem, or synthesis.
  • Develop formative assessments
    Match each quiz or task to its objective in complexity and format. Most programs express the mastery standard as a percentage, with guidance pointing to 80% to 90% and higher only for critical tasks.
  • Organize corrective activities
    Learners who miss the standard get correctives that present the concepts differently, involve them in new ways, and let them succeed. A second, parallel version of the assessment then checks whether the correctives worked.
  • Plan enrichment activities
    Learners who hit mastery on the first try can take on enrichment work, which should challenge and reward them.
  • Develop the summative assessment
    Align the final assessment with the objectives, the formative quizzes, and the instruction. This final assessment sets the unit or course grade.

Mastery learning example

A course creator selling a beginner Spanish course sets a learning goal for each unit, such as ordering food, and defines the mastery standard. Each unit ends with a short formative quiz. Anyone below the standard gets a corrective activity, a dialogue video in place of the original reading, then a parallel quiz. Learners who pass the first time get an enrichment role-play. A summative assessment closes the course.

FAQ

Bloom’s mastery learning approach is the strategy he named Learning for Mastery in 1968, later shortened to mastery learning. He drew on one-to-one tutoring, where a tutor flags an error and then explains it further, and asked what could carry over to group teaching.

Guskey reports that, against traditionally taught classes, evaluations consistently find better learning in mastery learning classes [2]. One 1987 review by Slavin, going against all earlier reviews, found essentially no effect on achievement. In Guskey’s view, that review used methods of doubtful validity.

Mastery learning grades learners only on their final assessment, measured against set standards instead of against peers. Simple pass or fail grades fit it well, though Guskey preferred adding an honors band to recognize work above expectations.

References

  1. Winget, M., & Persky, A. M. (2022). A practical review of mastery learning. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education (PMC).
  2. Guskey, T. R. (2001). Benjamin S. Bloom’s contributions to curriculum, instruction, and school learning. ERIC (ED457185).
  3. DeWeese, S. V., & Randolph, J. J. (2011). Effective use of correctives in mastery learning. ERIC (ED523991).

Related terms

Assessment and evaluation

Competency-based learning

Competency-based learning is an approach where learners advance by demonstrating defined skills and knowledge, at a pace that varies by learner.

Read definition

Assessment and evaluation

Formative assessment

Checking how learning is going during a course, so instructors and learners get feedback they can use to improve teaching and learning.

Read definition

Instructional design

Bloom’s Taxonomy

A framework that sorts learning goals into six levels of thinking, from recall to creation, and helps align assessments with those goals.

Read definition

Instructional design

Personalized learning

Personalized learning is instruction whose pace and teaching approach fit each learner's needs, with goals and content that may vary too.

Read definition

Published:

Last Update: